4. How do I store and prepare my pot pie once I’ve received it?

All our pot pies are fully cooked when you receive them. You can reheat them in a toaster oven or conventional oven. If frozen, we suggest using a toaster oven or conventional oven at 300° for about an hour. If you had time to take your pot pie out of the freezer the day before for some defrosting you can start with heating for half an hour, but these times are only approximate depending upon the temperature of your freezer, refrigerator and oven. We recommend not heating over 300° because the crust will start to burn before the filling gets heated through.  If microwaving, make sure to remove the bottom baking tin, but reheating this way could make the crust/pie a bit too soggy.

Because our pot pies are put into a blast freezer to preserve quality after they come out of the oven, they are then individually packaged and stored in a freezer until sold. They will last for quite a long time in the freezer.

Frequently asked questions

If you need help, we have a list of frequently asked questions and answers. We strive to give you the best buying experience possible. Click a question below to view the answer.

Our 6” pot pies are a healthy portion for one person, particularly, if you have a side dish of salad, or a lovely glass of wine. Or, a light meal for two if you both have a minor appetizer or want to save room for dessert.

We like to speak personally with our clients. We can make anything custom you’d like in a pot pie. Give us a call, and personally talk to Chef Wellington. We want to make sure you get exactly the product you desire. Our only business is to service our customers. Order by Email to info@wellingtonpotpies.com or call 201-446-2973.

Orders of 20 pies or more, and special orders, require a 50% payment at the time of order.

Yes, we ship! We deliver for free, or very low cost, within Bergen County (with a 4-pie-minimum order). We can otherwise provide a quote for shipping anywhere in the country. All deliveries are packaged in an insulated box.

All our pot pies are fully cooked when you receive them. You can reheat them in a toaster oven or conventional oven. If frozen, we suggest using a toaster oven or conventional oven at 300° for about an hour. If you had time to take your pot pie out of the freezer the day before for some defrosting you can start with heating for half an hour, but these times are only approximate depending upon the temperature of your freezer, refrigerator and oven. We recommend not heating over 300° because the crust will start to burn before the filling gets heated through.  If microwaving, make sure to remove the bottom baking tin, but reheating this way could make the crust/pie a bit too soggy.

Because our pot pies are put into a blast freezer to preserve quality after they come out of the oven, they are then individually packaged and stored in a freezer until sold. They will last for quite a long time in the freezer.

Bergen County New Jersey deliveries are free, or very low cost, depending upon your location. The minimum order is four pies. Shipping frozen pies are a bit more expensive due to the heavy weight and packing required. If you would like a quote please contact us either via e-mail or phone call with an address and how many pot pies you would like. We'll get back to you with the cost as soon as possible.

Because all of our products are handmade, we don’t keep a large inventory in stock.  All of our pot pies are flash frozen.  Drop us a line to find out what is available.  If we don’t have the variety of pot pies you want, we are happy to give you an estimated date you can expect them to be available.  Of course, lately, with the many supply chain issues, we can never know exact dates, but we will do our very best to make sure you get the pot pies you want.

At Wellington Pot Pies we pride ourselves on producing high quality wholesome foods. This is why we only use 100% US-sourced meats and vegetables that are always USDA approved. And, of course, our meat is raised and processed in the US. All products are handled with care to ensure our signature home-style taste. We stand out because unlike most mass-produced foods, there are never any preservatives or additives in our ingredients lists.